This post was written by Dark_Sage. He is Dark_Sage.
Yes, there is a reason 8th says this release is the best. The script’s pretty fabulous. Just ignore the shitty timing, lack of karaoke, and pathetic typesetting. Also, this post sucks, so just move along and note that CR has the best version.
Release format: 720p MKV (325 MB, 8-bit), “1080p” MKV (546 MB), 480p (148 MB)
Japanesiness: Honorifics.
Group website: http://www.crunchyroll.com/
8thsin’s translation critique: http://8ths.in/winter-2012-anime-subtitle-comparison/#Brave
Ji-hi’s screenshot comparisons: http://www.ji-hi.net/wi11/brave10/
Karaoke.
lol, none. This is a Crunchyroll rip. What did you expect?
Typesetting.
Script.
You’d think if they were going for a more formal style of speech for these characters that they’d be able to figure out the difference between “may”, “could”, and “can”. And there were other things I’d have changed that were super minor. There’s no reason to have the “after all” in “So that’s what they wanted after all.” and “I’m the only one allowed to shed blood fighting to the death with him.” is laughably terrible writing.
I didn’t take any screenshots because I’m not so sure any of those are really important enough to get pics and/or I’m feeling super fucking lazy right now.
Watchability: Quite watchable.
Overall grade: B+
Yeah, if you wanted to watch the show, go with the HorribleSubs version. The other groups sucked it.
”Masochist-chan” is a guy…….
No she isn’t. Which shit subs did you watch that fucked up that part of the show? Both Hiryuu and Crunchyroll specifically state that Wind-chan is a girl. Source: Episode 3, right after the fight as Saizo is leaving Maso-chan to bleed out. 19:58 in Crunchyroll’s script.
That’s right. She’s a girl. But, I’m pretty sure Hiryuu messed up in the next episode (episode 04) and referred her as “he”. So, if “Madoka” watched that…
Sorry. Seems like it’s kinda debatable about Yuri being a he or she.
It’s hermaphrodite.
^
I’m reading the manga (also the raws) and he shows in a chapter that he is a guy.
The mangaka loves feminine-looking guys.
Oh.
… I’d still hit it.
As long the person is pretty it doesn’t matter what the gender is.
what the… lol
A new Hideyoshi?
Hideyoshi doesn’t even has a gender (yes, I’m using has instead of have, because, Hideyoshi is “it”).
Men’s bath.
Women’s bath.
Hideyoshi’s bath.
There. It’s a new form of gender for Hideyoshi only. ^.^
B+… really ?? O_o