This post was written by Dark_Sage. He is Dark_Sage.
Yeah, another episode 1 review. Fuck this show; I have no interest in watching more than one episode of it.
Release format: MKV (184 MB, 10-bit)
Japanesiness: No honorifics.
English style: American English.
Group website: http://commiesubs.com/
Encoding details: http://pastebin.com/AEckaX0h
8thsin’s translation critique: N/A
Ji-hi’s screenshot comparisons: N/A
Table of Contents
Visual Quality
Karaoke.
Opening.
Ending.
For both the OP/ED, the kanji was hardsubbed by the animation studio. Can’t really fault Commie for rolling with it and using the same karaoke for the OP/ED.
Typesetting.
ALL CAPS LOCK FTW
Script Quality
Karaoke.
No hay problemos aquí, mis amigombres.
Main Script.
Too lengthy. Drop the “Excuse me” part.
…
I’d like to place my foot your editor’s face. :(
There’s no reason for a comma here. If you want an artificial pause, use an ellipsis.
Should be “shaggy-haired”.
Timing Review
Incoming. When “Timing Critique” is added as a category, you’ll know this part is done.
Results.
Watchability: Definitely watchable.
Timing Grade:
Visual grade: A-
Script grade: A-
Overall grade (timing results not factored in): A-
The few issues I did have with the release were relatively minor. In the end, this is a solid effort for a terrible anime. Good job, Commie.
Pretty sure the “Houston, Texas” and “Japan” signs were done by the studio.
Good catch.
Johnny Herkz, the name you can trust.
you don’t like the underlined line?
also the song styling is perfect thank you very much
Why did they label it as episode 81 though?
http://www.crymore.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Commie-Space-Brothers-01v2-710D9F8C.mkv_snapshot_03.51_2012.06.16_23.21.02.jpg
Ø
ø u.
ø guys, just tell him the diagonal slash is to show it’s not a O.
@Falsedawn, diagonal slashes are put in some fonts to distinguish between capital O and 0 (zero). 8 would have a horizontal slash.
Øhwow, I’ll have to be less subtle next time. I was just pointing out how fail the font is :D
No hay problemos aquí, mis amigombres.
I’d give your Spanish a F.
Soy disappointado mi espanol estoy mal.
Un molestar.
MOLESTAR.
Oh wow, all my poor Spanish is making me embarasado. Lo sienta.
Because I’m that skilled in Spanish:
*”making mi embarasado” has no sense, it’s like “it’s making me pregnant” xD
*”Sienta” is like “sit down”
Correct: “it’s making me avergonzado”, “lo siento”
BTW, good review. I’m following this series ’cause the lol, but you don’t have much of it until ep.3-4
ThatsTheJoke.jpg
“The few issues I did have with the release were relatively minor. In the end, this is a solid effort for a terrible anime.”
Man, why are you being this terribly subjective? To me, and many other people, this is a magnificent show.
Dark_Sage being opinionated? Say it ain’t so!
Dark Sage always hates the good shows of the season while praising shit like Horizon. Get used to it ;).
Don’t hate just because your brain was a tad too small to understand the story behind it.
Don’t hate just because your brain is so small that you have to desperately search for deep meaning amongst nonsense because you can’t accept that a show you liked sucked. I liked Horizon at first too but as the first season went on it became more and more clear that the writers didn’t have a fucking clue what they were doing and were just making it up as they went along. I expect season 2 to be more of the same.
No, don’t misunderstand, I don’t like the show at all. I actually dislike it. But if you read some of the light novels, you do get a more clear understanding of what is going on.
Well, it’s hardly the fault of my brain’s size that they decided to leave that shit out of the anime, is it? :P
I’m looking forward to more salty tears if Dark_Sage does Summer 2012 show previews.
To be honest, it’s also kind of refreshing to see somebody have questionable or bad (according to whom?) taste and be so unashamed of it. Too many people are pansies that need outside validation or are group-thinking anibloggers.
I agree with everything temp_late said.
An A- on visuals? I hope you screened all the most poorly-done signs in this ep, because /damn/.
Damn, we’re being herkzed in reverse.
Reverkz.
The Reverkz.
Sounds like a great dance move.
Yeah the typesetting is like a B- imo.
But dat styling.
The check will clear on Monday.
Oh by the way this is really a v2 in name only since the “v1” was an April Fool’s joke.
Need cryptw back.
Dem v10s.
‘Das middle school.
>terrible show
Oh well, its Dark Sage´s opinion, so…